CAAFlog
  • Home

CAAFlog

Bloomberg Article on Sex Assault Prosecution

4/22/2021

7 Comments

 
A Better Way Forward for Prosecuting Military Sexual Assaults​

"The current system for prosecuting members of the U.S. military for sex crimes is flawed, writes Kevin Carroll, a U.S. Army reservist who served as a military intelligence officer in Afghanistan and Iraq. Purely military offenses should remain in military court, he says, but Congress should allow other crimes to be tried in federal and state court systems."

The relevant passage:

"System Has Design Flaws

The design of the military justice system is inherently problematic. Commanders, who are non-lawyers, decide whether to prosecute, an authority we do not give governors or mayors (and try to keep distanced from presidents). Commanders evaluate prosecutors for promotion, in a way in which governors and mayors do not evaluate attorneys general or district attorneys.

Commanders also pick the service members who serve as jurors at the courts-martial they convene, which is unthinkable in a civilian context. The temptation to exercise “unlawful command influence” over the disposition of a case is often irresistible to the type-A personalities who wear stars.

While commendable efforts are made to insulate military judges and defense counsel from commanders’ pressure, and these good professionals take their ethical responsibilities seriously, the uniformed bar is insular, and the path to advancement narrow. There is no military correlate to the independence of a life-tenured Article III judge (or a New York state judge with a 14-year term, for example), or a federal defender who only reports to the chief judge of a circuit court of appeals.
Few active duty military lawyers have opportunities to clerk for civilian judges, or move between private practice, academia, or posts elsewhere in government, experiences which ideally broaden their civilian counterparts’ perspectives. Despite excellent JAG lawyers’ talents, military practice tends over time to lead toward more parochial views.

Judge advocates serve crucial roles beyond adjudicating criminal cases—in administrative and operational law, for example. And there is an irreducible number of military cases that JAGs alone can handle. Some proceedings unavoidably take place in war zones. Others are for crimes that have no counterpart in Title 18 of the U.S. Code, and appear only in the punitive articles of the Uniform Code of Military Justice (malingering, desertion, missing movement, disrespect, and misbehavior before the enemy). Purely military offenses still ought to be tried by, and in front of, service members.
​
But for crimes that can be tried at least as well by the federal and state court systems, including most sex crimes, Congress should tell the military to let civilian attorneys take the lead."

​Link here.
7 Comments
Scott
4/22/2021 10:47:26 am

Is there a way to access this article without an account?

Reply
William Cassara
4/22/2021 10:53:54 am

"An Army Intel Officer who served in Iraq and Afghanistan." I guess that makes him an expert.

Reply
Former DC
4/22/2021 03:19:27 pm

Can't read the article behind the paywall, but the quote makes it look like this intel officer wants to revisit Solorio (https://tile.loc.gov/storage-services/service/ll/usrep/usrep483/usrep483435/usrep483435.pdf).

Good on him - as a matter of policy I tend to agree, but I doubt that Congress is inclined to change sex assault prosecutions the way he thinks that would change things.

Reply
Philip D. Cave link
4/22/2021 05:09:43 pm

Like others, only reading the snippet, but if the snippet is representative, there may be something wrong here.

"Purely military offenses should remain in military court, he says, but Congress should allow other crimes to be tried in federal and state court systems."

When, if at all has Congress prohibited the military from allowing state and federal courts to prosecute cases involving a servicemember for CONUS cases?

I do agree that what Congress ought to do is adopt a service-connection test by statute--and if COngress doesn't the President should do so in the MCM by RCM.

Reply
Philip D. Cave link
4/22/2021 07:30:49 pm

https://news.bloomberglaw.com/us-law-week/a-better-way-forward-for-prosecuting-military-sexual-assaults-17

Reply
Lone Bear
4/23/2021 08:08:13 am

I was able to read, and agreed generally. Seems like he is proposing an NCIS type of independent prosecution office. It would restore a lot of faith in the system if there was an independent prosecution body, vice Convening Authority. Only the white, male colony of Flag officers can think that they should make decisions about prosecuting employees, versus trained prosecutors.

Reply
Tami a/k/a Princess Leia
4/23/2021 12:37:48 pm

Yes, the system is broken, because Congress made it that way. Congress can fix it by starting w/ preliminary hearings--no probable cause means no case. Require unanimous verdicts for all offenses. Cut down the hype over "eradicating" sexual assault, because it isn't going to happen. Start promoting "zero tolerance" of false reports of sexual assault to reduce the number of false complaints.

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Links
    CAAF
    -Daily Journal
    -Current Term Opinions
    ACCA
    AFCCA
    CGCCA
    NMCCA
    Joint R. App. Pro.
    Global MJ Reform
    LOC Mil. Law
    Army Lawyer
    Resources

    Categories

    All
    Daily Journal
    MJ Reform
    Question Time
    Scholarship
    Top Of The Year 2021
    Unanimous
    Week In Review

    Archives

    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020

The views expressed on this website are expressed in the authors' personal capacities.
Proudly powered by Weebly
  • Home