United States v. Bess. Those following the cert. petition with the U.S. Supreme Court previously reported here filed by Pedro Bess, a Black U.S. sailor challenging the secretive process of how panel members were selected where he was convicted by an all-white jury of sexual misconduct against white women. Many of us already argue that the convening authority has an unlimited number of peremptory challenges through the selection process so why should trial counsel have any at trial and the defense so few.
Petition. Government Response. Bess's Reply. Cheers, PC.
7 Comments
Isaac Kennen
6/6/2021 07:33:17 am
From the petition:
Reply
Lone Bear
6/6/2021 12:25:07 pm
Hope the Supremes give it a look. Bess really lays out some systemic problems, and the facts of this case makes some of the issues look intentional rather than just part of the process.
Reply
Reader
6/6/2021 08:07:44 pm
“This court cannot even be sure of the members’ race as the record is absent of any questions posed during voir dire to the members by either counsel or the military judge regarding the members’ racial or ethnic background.” Bess, NMCCA Slip Opinion, at 16.
Reply
6/7/2021 07:28:38 am
Was this case suitable for a Dubay hearing ordered by NMCCA (or CAAF)? If, on what little record there is and the seriousness of the issue, the defense had not done enough--Dubay?
Reply
Big Dawg
6/7/2021 06:31:58 pm
Phil, isn’t a Dubay hearing discretionary?
Reply
Lone Bear
6/7/2021 09:05:41 am
Seems like a head in the sand response to me, by an all white NMCCA panel. It was an all white panel, but turning a blind eye is easier for the court. Or blame the defense. I’m sure their voir dire questions to the all white panel should have been about how white they were, good start for the defense there. Any chance we can voir dire the court?
Reply
Your comment will be posted after it is approved.
Leave a Reply. |
Links
CAAF -Daily Journal -Current Term Opinions ACCA AFCCA CGCCA NMCCA Joint R. App. Pro. Global MJ Reform LOC Mil. Law Army Lawyer Resources Categories
All
Archives
April 2022
|